This is actually the third compilation Joey Yung has released within 6-7 years! And what's more a double disc this time! But is more really better?
There are 6 new tracks including the Prelude and Reprise. But the four new songs are not very impressive. Somehow, I don't really like "明日恩典" (Tomorrow's Grace), a song which includes bits of "Amazing Grace", that much. The idea of combining an old song with some new parts isn't new, and I actually like Gigi Leung's "Today" better than "Tomorrow's Grace". Joey's voice sounded a bit thin and my mum asked if it was Twins (my gosh!) singing!!! I also found her duet with Hacken Lee, "刻不容緩" (Hack But Yung Woon) quite ordinary and forgettable. I am actually looking forward to "容詩奇案" (Yung C Kei Onn, haha!) if it ever happens! It has been a long time since Denise and Joey collaborated in 1:99 live (not including the short JSG segment last year.) My favourite among the new songs is probably "呼天不應" (No One Cares), a very Joey-type song. But still, it can't beat "爭氣" (Buck Up) and "痛愛" (Painful Love), then-new songs from "Love Joey 2" and "Love Joey" respectively.
Okay, they say Joey can only sing K-songs, but that is when she's at her best. My favourite Joey songs are so-called 'K-ballads' like "一拍兩散" (Split Up), "心病" (Illness of the Heart), "心淡" (Fading), "痛愛", "誰來愛我" (Who Loves Me), and "逃避你"(Avoiding You), though she also has a few encouraging ones like "我的驕傲" (My Pride) and "爭氣". What's wrong with a girl singing songs with great tunes well? Those who dismiss her as a 'K-song'-only singer, try her songs in KTV and you will see that they are actually much harder to sing well than you think, as her vocal range is pretty wide!
I also like her fast-tempo songs like "隆重登場" (Appear on Stage) but I think it is a big mistake to make her sing silly ditties like "Chihuahua", which I thought is more suitable for Twins or something. I mean, songs like these don't help her cause to be taken as a serious singer at all, unless maybe her company thinks it can help capture more kids fans.
By her own admission, Joey is a simple girl who's only talent is 'being slightly better at singing than most people'. Her company decides what songs go into her albums and her job is just to sing them well, which she does. I don't really go deep into lyrics of her songs because they are mostly quite typical anyway. For example my most-played song in this compilation is probably "一拍兩散" but I don't really like the theme, about an attached girl who finds herself falling in love with another person and hating herself for it. I, however, was attracted by the melody and music arrangement. I love the flute bits in the song. Joey can play the flute and she did so at her 2002 concert. Though she didn't play it very well, at least she got full marks for the effort. And she has definitely come a long way since her early days. When I first watched her concert some years ago, I was wondering how many songs she could last before her voice would go. But by the time it came to her subsequent "Show Up!" and "Feel the Pop" concerts, she had blossomed into a respectable live singer. She, Sammi and hocc are the only really good female singers currently active in HK, in my opinion.
So I like Joey for her K-songs and simple character. I don't harbour great expectations for her songs to be terribly meaningful or to contain powerful messages. Maybe that's why she isn't my idol. Or maybe it's precisely because she isn't my idol, that's why I don't have such expectations. I leave that for Sammi and hocc. So I think it's sufficient to restrict myself to buying her compilations (incidently I bought all her Love Joey series of CDs) and concert DVDs. "Show Up" is the only all-new album I have by her and I suspect it may well be the only one. I do have her photobook and documentary VCD though, as I thought she is cute in her own way.
One thing about "Love Joey 3", the packaging is really attractive and I felt like a child opening a new toy! There is a Ziploc-type bag containing a colourful book with irregularly-shaped pages, and the two CDs contained inside. The book is actually a 10-question test to see how well you understand Joey. That was rather cute, I thought. But content-wise, I still prefer "Love Joey 2", a compact and tight selection of good songs. "Love Joey" was slightly premature as there obviously wasn't enough good material to include, while "Love Joey 3" had sort of spread itself a little thin by having 2 discs and including some songs repeated in the earlier compilations.